Picked up a dvd the other day I wasn’t expecting to ever see – the Boomtown Rats, live in 1978. I was pretty excited – the Rats hold a special place in my heart, being as they were one of my first forays out of the classic rock safety zone in 1986 (with The Fine Art of Surfacing album).
This concert is from the tour for the earlier A Tonic For the Troops, the other great Boomtown Rats record. The only time I’d ever seen them play anything was their Live Aid appearance in 85, and then Bob Geldof was already a minor saint (ie not a rock star). I wanted to see what they were like with the edges still on.
Well, I’m glad I saw it, because I think now I have a solid handle on what the Rats were about. There weren’t any edges. The band perform their songs reliably, but without soul, spirit or much energy. They strike some punk rock poses, but it’s all costume and props; if Toto or Boston had been told to Do Punk, they might have behaved very similarly on stage.
And Geldof, well, damn. If I were him I’d have disallowed this video’s release due to the pants he’s wearing. Jeeesus. Impossible not to stare at, especially if you’re bored with watching his Jaggerposing and posed earnestness.
I imagine, in reaction to the boringness of the footage, the producers of this recorded gig decided to help it out by superimposing topically relevant photos over the show – seriously. During I Never Loved Eva Braun, well, guess what pictures float across the screen? It’s pretty laughable. Sorry, but true.
The Boomtown Rats were always a seriously uneven band: of their five or six albums, only two are worth, in the end, paying attention to – but those two are really good. The band change their sound at the drop of a hat, but rarely to good or interesting effect. And for all of their post-punk posturing, there was always more art than anger in their songs – more Springsteen, less Dead Boys. When they’re trying their hardest to be punks, to sound punk (on Tonic) they remind me of another good record from the same era – the Monks’ Bad Habits – which riffed on punk without any real punk integrity. And why not? Who cares? Wasn’t that the point?
The group, whose last attempt at a single was famously blown away by Geldof’s own Do They Know It’s Christmas, ended in 1985. Bob Geldof has released intermittent albums since, mostly crappy in the same way his pal Sting’s albums are crappy. A couple of promo videos for Geldof’s latest record are graciously included on the DVD, and they’re entertaining, in an anthropological way. He did do one record that I loved for a long time, called The Vegetarians of Love; it doesn’t really hold up very well, but two or three tracks still work for me. One will probably still be on my Top-Whatever lists when I die:
Thinking Voyager Two Type Things.
I don’t want to give the impression that I hate the Boomtown Rats – I quite love the great bits. It’s just a drag that this DVD sucks. And it’s still a boon to have a glimpse into the band’s history, in that same anthropological way.
Here, let me show you some of the best stuff, and encourage you to pick up The Fine Art of Surfacing (1979) (but not the rerelease, I still frown on those.)
From The Fine Art of Surfacing:
Nothing Happened Today
Nice N Neat
[here's a link to the old badmonkeyx article on Fine Art of Surfacing, just for fun.]